With Thanksgiving only a few days away, many of you may be wondering: “What wine should I drink with the turkey this year?” Enter the French: Georges DuBoeuf vs. Louis Latour in a Beaujolais-Villages showdown. While this may not be the battle of the century, or even that hard-hitting of a fight (I haven’t met the pinot that was able to take me out), many would agree that a pinot noir is decent pairing for one of the largest turkey slayings of the year. And with good reason. The lighter style of the pinot is agreeable with most people’s palettes and pairs well with many of this holiday’s traditional dishes.
(I should note that both wines have been training since 2006 for this fight, and were allowed to breathe for one hour before consumption.)
Georges DuBoeuf: 2006 Beaujolais-Villages
While Georges’ offering appears to be the underdog of this battle with a floral-themed label, he has weighed in at a healthy $12 and has a nose that arguably smells of fresh-cut flowers, possibly even dandelions. It’s a very light wine, with a quick finish that’s chased by a faint jab of citrus.
While I will openly admit that I tend to enjoy the heavyweight matches a little more, it’s always fun to see what the lightweights can bring to the table.
Louis Latour: 2006 Beaujolais-Villages
Also weighing in at a spry $12 is Latour’s offering, which has a wicked cranberry-right cross. With a short, soft finish, this wine would also be a good choice for Thanksgiving dinner. And this may be a ridiculous critique, but I would feel much better about bringing a bottle of Louis Latour’s Beaujolais-Villages to a gathering of friends and family, the bottle just screams old school French style.
The decision:
Latour by a knockout. DuBoeuf simply lacked the refinement and experience that Latour brought to this match. While both wines fell safely within the pinot style, Latour was a slightly heavier, more refined wine than the DuBoeuf. And the DuBoeuf just felt young and unprepared for this battle.
Post-fight analysis:
At the end of the day, pairing wine with anything (especially Thanksgiving) just comes down to what you enjoy. If you would enjoy a gin and tonic with your Thanksgiving dinner, then by all means, please enjoy a tumbler of your favorite. And if you really worked at it, you could probably even convince me that it would be a reasonable pairing, as wild turkeys are often found roosting in pine trees. While this may or may not be utter nonsense, I hope that it serves to prove my point - drink what you like and enjoy the company. The holiday season is one of the few times a year that I get to raid my father’s cellar, and get away with it.
Happy Holidays!
-Ryan
